OK, I wasn’t planning on posting this, but this site is about perspective. And maybe this offers a different perspective of the speech Harrison Butker gave.
Most everyone has an opinion about the speech he gave to a Catholic college graduating class. Anyone just going off the sound bites of this speech should read the entirety. He covers way more than women’s roles.
He suggests the graduates choose their residence based on whether the church offers a Traditional Latin Mass, admonishes Catholics for using birth control, says bishops no longer care about sacraments, and quotes Taylor Swift (oh the irony). So many controversial opinions, but that’s not my point here.
The point here is that he didn’t recognize that his audience was bigger than Catholic graduates. It appears he didn’t know or care that even though he was speaking in his own “personal capacity” as a Christian Catholic, he was also representing something much larger. He was asked to speak because he was a member of the Super Bowl winning Kansas City Chiefs. It would be arrogant for him to think he was asked to speak because he was some good Catholic.
If he took time to understand he was representing something bigger than himself, he would have thought about his words and crafted something that truly honored women and motherhood. But he also would have considered how it affected his team and his employer. In the age of social media and access to every move, public figures always have more than one audience.
Because he didn’t recognize that, he caused conflict and division for fans, players, coaches, and people without any interest in the sport at all.
It irritates me to hear people say we shouldn’t judge because he was speaking in his “personal capacity.” It’s not about his right to speak his mind; it’s about who and what he is representing. There’s a tradeoff for making all that money by kicking a ball, Harrison. Your tradeoff is losing the privilege of “personal capacity.” You are now accountable for what you say and do based on your “public capacity.”
It’s a good reminder for all of us. We are always representing something bigger than ourselves when we speak. If we say things out of anger or judgment, can we excuse ourselves by saying, “Well that was just in my personal capacity?”
But what about how it impacts our partners, children, grandchildren, friends, coworkers, companies we work for? What we say and do impacts so many others. Most of us are not in the public spotlight, but we’re in someone’s spotlight.
It was never just his personal capacity. I need to remember it’s not just mine either.










